After playing with the pieces a bit during actual construction, I did change up my design a bit, and ended up with this for the top:
And here is the completed pillow I made for my (still secret) partner:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/24a3e/24a3ed5264905a9f00a2d50d029286d14781a5eb" alt="Finished Pillow"
I quilted it with lines 1/4" apart, and added a zipper at the bottom for inserting and removing the pillow form.
I sure hope you like this partner. :)
<3 Kelsey